Parker Tax Pro Library
online tax research Parker Tax
CPA Client Letter Samples
tax and accounting
CPA Client Letter Samples

District Court: Government Cannot Reverse Abatement of Penalty by IRS

(Parker Tax Publishing October 2026)

A district court held that the government could not abate a taxpayer's penalty and then reinstate it after finding the abatement had been a mistake because the case had already been referred to the Department of Justice. The district court rejected the government's argument that the abatement was an unauthorized compromise under Code Sec. 7122(a) which the government could reverse. Groves v. U.S., 2026 PTC 288 (N.D. Ill. 2026).

Background

Philip Groves buys, sells, and services distressed Chinese debt. In 2015, the IRS sent Groves a Notice of Proposed Adjustment for violating Code Sec. 6700 by engaging in unlawful tax shelter transactions. Groves subsequently received a Notice of Penalty Charge that gave him two options for paying the penalty: (1) pay the penalty in full and seek a refund; or (2) pay 15 percent of the penalty and file a claim for refund, with the further obligation to file a lawsuit in district court within 30 days after denial of the refund claim. Groves took the second option, paid 15 percent of the penalty, and filed a refund claim with the IRS on the grounds that he did not engage in the alleged tax shelter conduct. The IRS rejected the claim, sent Groves a Final Notice of Intent to Levy, and informed him that he was entitled to a Collection Due Process (CDP) or equivalent hearing. Once the case was on file, lawyers from the Department of Justice (DOJ) appeared to represent the United States.

At Groves' request, a CDP-equivalent hearing was held. After the hearing, Groves amended his complaint to add the additional contention that the penalty was also invalid under Code Sec. 6751(b), which requires agents to receive a supervisor's written confirmation before determining a penalty. Years later, the IRS sent Groves a determination that his penalty had been abated because the IRS had failed to comply with Code Sec. 6751(b).

The government subsequently argued that it had erroneously abated Groves' tax penalty. According to the government, the penalty abatement constituted a compromise and, under Code Sec. 7122(a), the abatement was unauthorized because the case had already been referred to the DOJ. The government claimed that it can reverse any unauthorized abatement of a penalty and reinstate the penalty. The government's main justification for this about-face rested on Code Sec. 7122 which authorizes "the Attorney General or his delegate" to "compromise" any case arising under the Code after the case has been referred to the DOJ for defense. In the government's view, the abatement was void because the IRS lacked the authority to abate Groves' tax liability once the case had been referred to the DOJ.

Groves moved for summary judgment, arguing that because the penalty abatement he received was not a "compromise," the government lacked the authority to reverse or ignore it.

Analysis

The district court held that the abatement of the penalty was not a compromise under Code Sec. 7122(a), so that provision did not invalidate the abatement. The court further held that no exception applied that would allow for the abatement to be reversed.

The court found that the abatement of Groves' penalty was not a compromise under Code Sec. 7122(a) because the term "compromise" means "to come to agreement by mutual concession." After carefully reviewing (1) the plain language of the word "compromise"; (2) Code Sec. 7122's other subsections and uses of the term "compromise"; (3) the structure of the Code; and (4) relevant administrative materials, the court determined that, because the abatement of the penalty was unilateral and Groves conceded nothing, the abatement was not a compromise within the meaning of the statute.

In the court's view, Code Sec. 7122 suggests that a compromise requires a taxpayer to pay something. Most notably, Code Sec. 7122(c)(1) requires a taxpayer to make a partial payment when she first submits an offer in compromise. The court also reasoned that the Code does not treat the terms "abatement" and "compromise" as interchangeable. Code Sec. 7122 provides rules for determining when and how the IRS may compromise, while Code Sec. 6404 sets forth rules governing abatements. The court noted that Code Secs. 7122 and 6404 are in separate chapters of the Code and there are no cross-references between them. Structure alone is not authoritative, the court observed, but it suggested that Congress did not intend to conflate the terms abatement and compromise.

For a discussion of what constitutes an offer in compromise, see Parker Tax ¶263,165.



Parker Tax Pro Library - An Affordable Professional Tax Research Solution. www.parkertaxpublishing.com

Disclaimer: This publication does not, and is not intended to, provide legal, tax or accounting advice, and readers should consult their tax advisors concerning the application of tax laws to their particular situations. This analysis is not tax advice and is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for purposes of avoiding tax penalties that may be imposed on any taxpayer. The information contained herein is general in nature and based on authorities that are subject to change. Parker Tax Publishing guarantees neither the accuracy nor completeness of any information and is not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for results obtained by others as a result of reliance upon such information. Parker Tax Publishing assumes no obligation to inform the reader of any changes in tax laws or other factors that could affect information contained herein.